When I heard a verdict had been announced in the Casey Anthony trial, I breathed a sigh of relief. It had only taken the sequestered jury two days to deliberate before they reached a unanimous decision — more than enough time to establish that Anthony murdered her two-year-old daughter, Caylee, and assign guilt to her. Then, I read the verdict: not guilty. Not guilty? Not guilty of what? No one has been this clearly guilty of murder since OJ Simpson. Whoa…that’s weird.
As it turns out, a lack of physical evidence against Anthony was compounded by blurry lines drawn up by her defense team. Even though this vile woman was seen drinking and dancing while her daughter’s corpse rotted in the trunk of her car, her attorneys managed to paint her as a victim of unfortunate circumstances. Despite a documented history of crack addiction, Anthony was depicted as a caring, devastated mother whose pronounced grief had been misinterpreted as drug-crazed indifference. We had all been unfair, counsel reasoned, to characterize this ‘victim’ as a demonically amoral slut that was capable of the worst crime imaginable.
I stand by my judgment. There was no aspect of this trial that caused me to doubt her culpability in little Caylee’s death. Her ‘alibi’ consisted of a string of excuses, held together with nonsensical logic. She didn’t report her own child’s ‘abduction’ for nearly a month, simply because she wasn’t concerned. When her parents confronted her about Caylee’s absence, Casey claimed that the girl had been missing for 10 days. Her body was recovered in a forest six months after she disappeared, and though police suspected the little girl’s body has sat in the trunk of her mother’s car prior to its disposal, they couldn’t pin anything on her.
Casey Anthony is either the luckiest murderer in the world – or the smartest. I’m not too keen on saying it’s the latter, though. It seems quite clear that her behavior following Caylee’s killing certainly did not rule her out as the murderer. If anything, this conduct merely exacerbated the notion Casey was guilty. What kind of a woman would ever entertain the idea of partying while her only child was missing? The answer, of course, is a sociopath – which is exactly what Casey Anthony is. How did these twelve individuals collectively fall for her crocodile tears? Well, the defense earned their paycheck during the jury selection.
Speaking of these lawyers – I can’t decide if I feel loathing or admiration for them. Casey Anthony is a free woman (for now) because of their efforts, but they were just doing their jobs. Doing the hell out of them, in fact. Defense lawyers have a slimy reputation, and it’s somewhat deserved in many cases but ultimately it’s unfair. At the very least, the same attribute should be ascribed to prosecutors. When the wrong man is convicted, aren’t the district attorneys responsible for injustice that is comparable to setting a guilty person free? It’s a funny world we live in, where men and women make a living – and a good one at that – by placing obstacles along the path toward justice and equality. This is certainly not true of all lawyers, or even very many – they know who they are, let’s say.
I had a discussion with a good friend today – one who earned a Bachelor’s degree in Criminal Justice. The way he put it was, yes, Casey Anthony is probably guilty of murder, but the same system that has enabled her freedom is also ultimately the catalyst for countless others that receive exactly what’s coming to them – no more, no less. Anthony represents the unfortunate exception to the inherent fairness provided by our judicial branch. OJ was another. I argued that these two are pretty large exceptions. Sure, I can tell people that my car is designed to keep me safe, except for that one time the brake line snapped and I plowed down a family of five at a crosswalk. Of course my car is designed to keep me safe, but what about the family of five? What about Caylee Anthony? Are we truly all right with just calling them collateral damage and moving on?
I respect my friend’s opinion – his opinion on these matters is much more informed than mine – but it doesn’t make me feel any better. Here’s why: simply put, if our court system is unable to punish a woman as clearly guilty as Casey Anthony, then how can we say it’s legitimate? If a crack whore is able to circumvent our legal process, then the waters must be pretty easy to navigate. Now, reportedly, Anthony is writing a book – about her triumph in the courtroom, no doubt. Well, OJ wrote a book called If I Did It. Maybe Anthony could call hers Why I Did It. How I Did It. I Couldn’t Find A Babysitter. I Let My Daughter Decompose In My Trunk And All I Got Was This T-shirt. It practically titles itself.
I have no doubt that Anthony’s lifestyle will take care of her in the same – albeit, much more tragic — way it took care of her daughter. Sometimes, problems handle themselves. I listen to Curtis Mayfield, I know how it works – though it doesn’t seem like that’s enough, does it? When Casey Anthony spends her final moments lying on a pile of trash while a bad batch courses through her bloodstream, it’s pathetic – but it doesn’t right any wrongs. This woman should spend the rest of her life in prison – and on suicide watch, for that matter. When she comes down from her high, it’d probably be good if she didn’t have shoelaces readily available to her. Realizing you killed your kid and losing a buzz is a pretty rough combination – and you’re in a locked cell, to boot.
This one is really hard to swallow, for me. In fact, I’ll even say that you should be as angry about this as I am. It’s all right to get mad when people like Casey Anthony are allowed to walk the Earth in the same manner as you and I, without any sort of barrier that deprives them of our generous, Earthly bounty. Ripe peaches, Bose headphones, jet skis, sunny days, good sex — all the lavish benefits to freedom that, incidentally, will never be experienced by Caylee Anthony.
Here’s a test: if this one fails, I’m moving to Canada. Today, in California, a teenage boy named Larry McInerny, 14, appeared in court for the first time. He is accused of killing Lawrence King, a gay 15-year old classmate by shooting him twice in the back of the head (that’s execution-style, if you didn’t know). His reasoning for the crime is rooted in white supremacist ideology, which he had exposed himself to in the month’s preceding his crime. McInerny’s defense attorney has implicated the victim as the instigator, pointing to numerous unwanted sexual advances toward his killer. What I’m proposing is that, if McInerny is found not guilty – and King is vilified as a sexual predator – we throw out the whole doctrine and start from scratch. The insanity needs to stop.
Enough about that. Caylee Anthony needs to be honored, first and foremost. We should all mourn her in the way her own mother never did, and remember that children are a blessing – not a burden. Hug your kids and tell them how much you love them – that’s my plan, when I’m fortunate to have my own. It’s the best way to memorialize the boys and girls who were never given a chance in hell to be happy.
















